Eagle Rare 10 Year Old Review

A bottle of Eagle Rare 10


Eagle Rare 10 has been a personal favorite of mine ever since I first started drinking bourbon. It is also almost certainly the coolest looking bottle on the market with that majestic eagle on the front!

Eagle Rare 10 is a single barrel bourbon made by the Buffalo Trace distillery and this offering is basically the standard Buffalo Trace but aged for 10 long years. It uses the number 1 Mashbill, believed to consist of 10% or less rye. The original was a 101 proof bourbon that was produced from 1975 to 2005 by Seagram and then The Sazerac Company and was created by Charles Beam.

About the Distillery

Back in the days of the Wild West, when pioneers and explorers opened new frontiers, some followed an old buffalo trail that led them to the Kentucky River’s banks. The town of Frankfort was born, the home of the Buffalo Trace Distillery, and destined to become Kentucky’s capital city.

Claiming to be the oldest operating distillery in the U.S., a fact attested to by the Guinness Book of Records, Buffalo Trace is still a family-owned business. The original distillery was built in 1812. In 1886, they installed America’s first climate-controlled warehouse dedicated to the aging of whisky.

The original distillery building was burnt to the ground in 1882. During recent renovations, its foundations were discovered and can now be seen by visitors touring the site.

Apart from its celebrated range of exceptional bourbons, Buffalo Trace is also famous for being allowed to remain operational during the era of Prohibition for medicinal purposes.

Buffalo Trace also put out the Eagle Rare 17 as part of the much-lauded Buffalo Trace Antique Collection (BTAC) and I’m a big fan of that too, I haven’t tried the latest version yet but really enjoyed many previous bottlings..

Considering the original juice is pretty damn good to start with it can only get better after 10 years in a barrel, right? Have a read of my review to find out.

A close up of the Eagle Rare 10 label

Whiskey Info

This is what they say on the bottle:

“Eagle Rare 10 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey has a sweet, oaky nose and full, complex body. Reminiscent of a fine port wine, this rare whiskey is best served neat, of over ice. Of course, feel free to drink Eagle Rare in such classic cocktails as the Manhattan or Whiskey sour”

Distiller: Buffalo Trace

ABV: 45%

Proof: 90

Age Statement: 10 Years

Cask Type: New Charred Oak Barrels

Mashbill: Not known exactly – #1 Mashbill from Buffalo Trace

Website: http://www.buffalotracedistillery.com/brands/eagle-rare

Tasting Notes


Dark fruits, cherries, banoffee pie, caramel, crème Brule, leather and Werther’s Originals.


A touch of vanilla to kick things off then layers of dark fruit, caramel, honey, corn, a hint of orange, glazed cherries and baking spice. One of the fruitiest bourbons I have tried. Great flavors.


It’s already won me over by the time I get to the finish but it’s fruity again but more like the fruitiness you get from boiled sweets, Jolly ranchers maybe? Or is that just absurd?! A bit of oak and some sweet fudge rounds it off.


I love how fruity this is, you often get slight hints of fruit in bourbons but for me, dark fruits are the dominating flavor in this and that makes it both unique and delicious.

It’s just a very well rounded bourbon and it is very reasonably priced for a 10 year release, meaning it makes a great daily drinker to have on the shelf. It has been known to vary slightly in quality from batch to batch but is generally very dependable.

Also works well as a drink to give newbies and is awesome in a cocktail and not too expensive.

The critics seem to agree that this is a great bourbon as well, it has won countless awards over the years.

It is definitely worth picking up a bottle.

Eagle Rare 10 Rating
Reader Rating7 Votes